Last Updated: November 10, 2026
Potbelly Sandwich Shop is a casual chain that started in Chicago and built its identity around toasted sandwiches, a cozy atmosphere and a straightforward menu. Sandwiches are warmed on a conveyor oven so the bread comes out crisp and the fillings heated through. If you are new to Potbelly, the menu can look simple but offers a number of ways to customize. This guide explains the categories, starter picks, and ordering tips.
Menus, availability and limited-time items vary by location and change often. Please verify current offerings on the official Potbelly menu or app before you order.
What Potbelly Is Known For
The restaurant is known for toasted sandwiches served warm, with a variety of meats, cheeses and toppings. The signature approach includes a choice of bread and toppings such as lettuce, tomato, onion, pickles, hot peppers and oil and vinegar. A sandwich called A Wreck, which combines multiple meats such as salami, roast beef, turkey and ham, has become a popular signature. Milkshakes, cookies and soups are also associated with the brand.
The original stores were designed to feel like a neighborhood shop, and many locations continue to use warm, retro styling. Some restaurants have featured live music or local touches, though that varies.
Main Menu Categories
Sandwiches
Core sandwiches include Italian, Turkey Breast, Roast Beef, Meatball, Tuna Salad, Chicken Salad, Mediterranean-style vegetarian sandwiches, and A Wreck. Most can be ordered in sizes labeled Original, Big or Skinny, with the smaller option typically appealing to lighter appetites. Bread choices usually include white, multigrain wheat, and a jalapeno cheese bread at some locations.
Hot Options
The toasted nature of the menu means many sandwiches are hot by default, such as the Meatball and the Pizza-style options at certain stores. Cold sandwiches can be ordered untoasted on request.
Salads
Salads include chopped and chicken-topped options, built with greens and standard deli toppings. They provide an alternative for those not wanting bread.
Soups and Mac
Soups are a regular part of the lineup and rotate regularly. Broccoli cheese, tomato and chili are among the types often seen. Mac and cheese appears at many locations as a comfort-style side.
Sides
Chips, pickles and cookies are the standard sides. A baked cookie, such as oatmeal chocolate chip, is a familiar finish.
Shakes and Desserts
Hand-dipped style milkshakes and malts are a signature part of the dessert list. Typical flavors include vanilla, chocolate and strawberry, plus seasonal options at times.
Drinks
Fountain drinks, bottled beverages and iced tea are common. Some locations offer coffee or specialty beverages.
What First-Timers Might Try
- A Wreck: the multi-meat signature, offering a mix of flavors in one sandwich.
- Italian: a classic with salami, pepperoni, ham and toppings like hot peppers and oil.
- Turkey Breast toasted: a straightforward sandwich that benefits from the warm bread.
- A cup of soup with a half sandwich: an easy way to try two items.
- A milkshake: a classic treat to round out a meal.
Customization and Ordering Tips
The assembly line at Potbelly is quick and approachable. After choosing a sandwich, you pick a size, a bread and any adjustments. The staff then asks about toppings. If you are unsure, ask for the sandwich as it comes by default and add extras later.
- Select a size with your appetite in mind. The Skinny size is popular for lighter meals, while the Original size is the standard.
- Ask for toasting based on the filling. Meats and cheese generally benefit from toasting, while some fresh toppings are best added after.
- Add hot peppers or pickles for contrast. These are common toppings that add acidity and spice.
- Use oil and vinegar sparingly at first. A little goes a long way, and you can ask for more.
- Pair with soup or a shake. These items are popular add-ons that round out a meal.
The Potbelly app and website offer ordering ahead, delivery and rewards. Catering options include sandwich platters, boxed lunches and bags of cookies, which are popular for offices and group events. For dietary needs, review the official menu and allergen information. Bread and topping choices can often be adjusted to avoid ingredients, though cross-contact can occur in a shared assembly area.
Planning Your Visit
Potbelly shops are often located in downtown areas, office districts and shopping centers, so lunch is the busiest period. If you are visiting at midday, expect a line that moves steadily, since sandwiches are assembled and toasted quickly. A relaxed approach is to decide on a sandwich before reaching the counter, then use the toppings step to fine-tune it. Pairing a Skinny sandwich with a cookie or a shake is a common way to keep a meal manageable while still enjoying a treat. Ordering through the app is a useful way to skip the line when time is short.
Quick-Reference Table
| Category | Typical Items | Good For |
|---|---|---|
| Sandwiches | A Wreck, Italian, Turkey Breast, Roast Beef, Meatball, Tuna Salad, Chicken Salad | Toasted deli meals |
| Sizes | Original, Big, Skinny | Matching appetite |
| Breads | White, multigrain wheat, jalapeno cheese (select stores) | Changing flavor |
| Salads | Chopped salads, chicken salads | Skipping the bread |
| Soups and Mac | Rotating soups, mac and cheese | Comfort sides |
| Shakes | Vanilla, chocolate, strawberry, seasonal | Dessert |
| Cookies | Oatmeal chocolate chip and others | A sweet finish |
Menu Variation by Location
Menus, availability and limited-time items vary by location and change often. Soup choices, breads, shake flavors and seasonal sandwiches may differ from store to store. Some locations are franchised and may carry slightly different offerings. Check the official Potbelly menu or app for the details at your restaurant.
FAQ
What is A Wreck at Potbelly?
A Wreck is a signature sandwich that combines several deli meats, typically salami, roast beef, turkey and ham, with cheese and toppings.
Are all Potbelly sandwiches toasted?
Most are toasted by default, but you can ask for a sandwich to be served untoasted if you prefer.
What are the sandwich sizes?
Sandwiches commonly come in Original, Big and Skinny sizes, with availability depending on the location.
Does Potbelly offer catering?
Yes. Catering includes sandwich platters, boxed lunches and cookies, and can be ordered through the official channels.
6 Best Kids Water Slides (November 2026)
7 Best Power Scrubbers (November 2026)
